November offers an unusually revealing glimpse into Finland's relationship with entrepreneurship. As a professor of entrepreneurship at Aalto University, I work in an environment where entrepreneurial ambition and experimentation are enthusiastically encouraged. We tell aspiring founders to think big, challenge conventions, test their ideas and learn from failure. Indeed, the university has been very successful in creating growing startups, as 8 out of the 10 unicorns from Finland have their roots at Aalto. Finland's startup ecosystem has become remarkably successful at cultivating the founder mindset, and the Slush event in Helsinki every November is a culmination of that celebration. At Slush, we celebrate a particular entrepreneurial individual: the ambitious, innovative, internationally oriented founder.
Just the week before Slush, on November 12, the country observed its annual “veropäivä” (tax day), when information about individuals' taxable incomes became public and the media reported on the country's highest earners. Although making people’s tax information public sounds unusual by international standards, Finland's tax administration identifies openness and public debate as reasons for making the information available. Thus, on tax day, public attention turns to wealth as a measure of individual success.
The two events, tax day and Slush, are closely related: those at the top of the tax-paying chart tend to be startup entrepreneurs. So during one November week, we examine the income that successful individuals have accumulated. Then, during the next, we celebrate entrepreneurs who aspire to create companies that might eventually generate substantial personal wealth.
This public discussion, with its emphasis on startups, their founders’ ambitions, and their wealth, risks drawing attention away from what entrepreneurship, at its core, is all about. Entrepreneurship is not defined by who founders are, what characteristics they possess, or which categories their companies belong to, but by what entrepreneurs actually do. Entrepreneurship is fundamentally about action: the activities through which individuals create new organizations, mobilize resources, and turn ideas into businesses.
This call to recalibrate the conversation on entrepreneurship is not new. Nearly four decades ago, entrepreneurship professor William B. Gartner challenged the prevailing entrepreneurship scholarship in his influential 1988 article, titled “Who Is an Entrepreneur? Is the Wrong Question”. In short, Gartner argued for shifting attention from who entrepreneurs are to what they do. This insight remains remarkably relevant in the discussion of Finnish entrepreneurship today. If entrepreneurship is fundamentally about what people do, rather than who they are or what kinds of companies they establish, we should focus more on the actions behind entrepreneurial success and how to encourage them across different contexts. If we fail to do this, we have to deal with at least three types of problems:
How can you learn to be an entrepreneur?
First, and closest to my heart as an entrepreneurship educator, if being a startup founder is described as a status rather than a set of behaviors, there is little we can do to teach it. I regularly encounter students who have already decided that entrepreneurship is not for them. They look at celebrated startup founders and see people who are exceptionally ambitious, confident, technically talented, or willing to take enormous risks. They do not recognize themselves in these descriptions, and conclude that to be successful in entrepreneurship, they need to become someone else. This is frustrating, as what really differentiates an entrepreneur from the rest is that an entrepreneur takes action to solve a problem when facing one. It is all in the doing. By focusing on what entrepreneurs do rather than who they are, we can help more people recognize that entrepreneurship is something they can learn and practice.
How can SMEs grow?
Second, focusing more on what entrepreneurs do could help us make entrepreneurial behaviors more widely understood, valued, and practiced across different types of businesses. Finland, similar to many other countries, is home to two different worlds of entrepreneurship within one country. There is an internationally admired startup ecosystem where innovation and ambitious growth are enthusiastically encouraged. These same behaviors can be equally important for established small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs), many of which have the capabilities and potential to grow but struggle to find new paths forward. In practice, however, startups and SMEs are often treated as belonging to separate worlds, with few opportunities to learn from one another. This separation is unfortunate because the behaviors needed for growth are often remarkably similar. Established SMEs could benefit from startup-like behaviors (think of a family-owned business experimenting with a new export market, or a service company using digital technologies to reach a new customer segment), while startups could learn from the accumulated experience and established customer relationships of SMEs. By paying greater attention to entrepreneurial actions rather than company categories, we could make innovation and growth more accessible to a much broader range of Finnish businesses.
How can everyone be encouraged to act entrepreneurially?
Third, treating startups as a distinct category also allows us to attach very different meanings and values to entrepreneurial activity depending on who undertakes it. One particularly revealing example in Finland concerns the so called “suojaosa”, which is the amount of income that unemployed individuals could previously earn (EUR 300) without reducing their unemployment benefits. The allowance applied to earnings from part-time employment and self-employment alike, but its removal in 2024 also reduced the financial incentives for unemployed individuals to experiment with small-scale entrepreneurial activities. While we enthusiastically encourage startup founders to experiment and pursue opportunities, our social security system has made similar experimentation financially more difficult for unemployed individuals seeking to create a modest source of income through self-employment. For them, experimentation and pursuing a business opportunity becomes primarily an issue of benefit eligibility and employment status. The activities themselves may be entrepreneurial in much the same way, even if their scale and immediate ambitions differ. Clearly, our understanding of entrepreneurship is shaped by the categories we assign to people.
To be sure, startups are worth celebrating, and they have characteristics that make them distinct. Their pursuit of scalable business models with external capital, and potential to create entirely new markets, make them important drivers of innovation and economic growth. Yet entrepreneurial behaviors are valuable well beyond the startup ecosystem. If we genuinely want to encourage entrepreneurship throughout Finnish society, we should make it easier for individuals to experiment with self-employment while receiving unemployment benefits, help established SMEs discover new paths to growth, create stronger connections between startups and established businesses, and make entrepreneurial skills more accessible through education. Ultimately, our ambition should extend beyond creating more successful startups to enabling more people and businesses across Finland to act entrepreneurially and create economic value for themselves and their communities.